All Paragon for me. I'd like to think the Paragon options wouldnbe how I would react to the given situations. (They do make more sense when I play the game.) Plus this world needs to get back to "nice guy" heroes again! Enough with these anti-social neanderthals, I like being an officer and a gentleman!
Finally someone makes Guy Shepard the good guy. I personally always thought Jennifer Hale's voice acting sounded passionate, fiery, and fierce. While Mark Meer's sounded more calm, centered, and steady.
Cool! Both paths are great, but seriously, regardless of gender, renegade Shep has some of the best quotes and dialogue in the game. "You can either follow me or get crushed under my heel, but you will NOT get in my way!" "Hey everybody! This store discriminates against the poor!"